While “Soulseeker” may not have cracked mainstream charts, it has achieved something arguably more valuable: underground respect. On forums like Reddit’s r/firehouse and Discogs, users praise its “timeless feel” and “effortless swing.” A reviewer on Junodownload called it “a late-night gem that reveals new details after the third listen.” On Spotify, the track has accumulated hundreds of thousands of streams — a significant number for a release on an independent label without major playlist placement.